What is the breakdown for defamation?
California defamation: basic framework
In California, defamation is either libel or slander. A plaintiff generally must prove a false, defamatory, unprivileged statement of fact, published to someone other than the plaintiff, that was about the plaintiff and caused legally recoverable harm. The required level of fault and available damages depend on whether the plaintiff is a private or public figure, whether the matter is of public concern, and whether the statement is actionable on its face.[7]
1. Identify the kind of publication
| Claim | What it covers | California definition |
|---|---|---|
| Libel | Written or otherwise fixed communications, including publications in a form visible to the eye | A false and unprivileged publication that exposes someone to hatred, contempt, ridicule, or obloquy, causes the person to be shunned or avoided, or tends to injure the person in their occupation.[6] |
| Slander | Spoken communications and certain other communications | A false and unprivileged oral publication that falls within a statutory category or naturally causes actual damage.[3] |
For slander, the statutory categories include accusing someone of a crime; imputing an infectious, contagious, or loathsome disease; directly injuring the person in their work or business in specified ways; imputing impotence or lack of chastity; or causing actual damage by natural consequence.[3]
2. Work through the elements
The California Supreme Court describes the tort as requiring a publication that is false, defamatory, unprivileged, and has a natural tendency to injure or causes special damage.[7] In practice, analyze each of these points:
- Publication: Was the statement communicated to at least one person other than the plaintiff? The CACI instructions require communication to a person or persons other than the plaintiff. CACI No. 1704[1]
- Of and concerning the plaintiff: Would the recipient reasonably understand the statement to refer to the plaintiff? A person need not necessarily be named if the audience could identify them from context.
- Defamatory meaning: Would the statement tend to harm the plaintiff’s reputation, such as by lowering the person in the estimation of others or discouraging association or business?
- Falsity: Is the challenged assertion false? A statement that is substantially true is generally not actionable as a falsehood.
- Fact, not protected opinion: Can the statement be proved true or false, or does it imply undisclosed defamatory facts? The court first decides whether the statement is reasonably capable of a defamatory factual meaning; context matters. CACI No. 1707[2]
- Unprivileged: Does an absolute or qualified privilege apply? Privilege is a separate and often dispositive issue.
- Fault: What level of care or culpability must the plaintiff prove? This depends on the plaintiff’s status and the subject of the statement.
- Harm and damages: What injury was caused, and what categories of damages are available?
3. Distinguish defamation per se from per quod
| Category | Meaning | Main consequence |
|---|---|---|
| Per se | The statement is defamatory on its face, without needing additional facts to explain its defamatory meaning. | A plaintiff may be able to recover presumed reputational damages without proving specific economic loss, subject to constitutional limits and the applicable claim. |
| Per quod | The statement becomes defamatory only when considered with extrinsic facts or circumstances. | The plaintiff must plead and prove the facts supplying the meaning and, for libel, special damages as required by statute. |
California’s statute defines libel on its face as defamatory without explanatory matter or extrinsic facts. Language not libelous on its face is not actionable unless the plaintiff alleges and proves special damage as a proximate result.[5] The California Supreme Court likewise distinguishes per se statements from per quod statements, for which the injurious meaning or effect must be established by allegation and proof.[4]
Important distinction: A statement’s being “per se” does not eliminate the need to establish the other elements, including falsity, publication, and lack of privilege. Nor does it necessarily permit presumed or punitive damages in every constitutional setting.
4. Match fault and damages to the plaintiff and subject matter
The key questions are who the plaintiff is and whether the statement concerns a matter of public concern.
- Private figure; private concern: The CACI instruction for this category requires proof that the defendant failed to use reasonable care to determine the statement’s truth or falsity. It describes actual damages and, for defamation per se, assumed damages for reputational harm and emotional injury. CACI No. 1704[1]
- Private figure; public concern: Negligence may suffice for actual injury, but presumed or punitive damages generally require proof of constitutional actual malice. California authority describes actual malice as knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard of whether the statement was false.[1][8]
- Public official or public figure: The plaintiff generally must prove actual malice when the challenged statement concerns the relevant public role or controversy. “Actual malice” is a term of art: it means knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard of truth, not simply hostility or ill will.[8] The court, not the jury, determines whether the plaintiff is a public figure.[1]
For actual damages, CACI identifies possible harm to property, business, trade, profession, or occupation; expenses caused by the statement; reputational harm; and shame, mortification, or hurt feelings. CACI No. 1704[1] Punitive damages require clear and convincing evidence of malice, oppression, or fraud under the cited instruction. CACI No. 1704[1]
5. Screen for defenses and privileges early
- Truth: Falsity is part of the claim, so evidence that the statement is true or substantially true is central.
- Opinion: Pure opinion is not actionable, but wording framed as opinion may still be actionable if, in context, it implies a false factual assertion. CACI No. 1707[2]
- Common-interest privilege: A communication made without malice to an interested person by someone also interested may be protected. The defendant generally must establish the privileged occasion; the plaintiff then must show malice to defeat the privilege.[9][7]
- Litigation or other statutory privilege: California recognizes an absolute privilege for specified official and judicial proceedings, subject to statutory limits. The particular communication and setting matter.[9]
- Identification, context, and audience: Even without a name, a statement may identify a plaintiff to recipients who know the relevant circumstances. Conversely, lack of a reasonable identification or defamatory factual meaning may defeat the claim.
Practical case-screening checklist
For each challenged statement, collect:
- The exact words, publication format, date, and recipient or audience.
- Facts showing why the statement refers to the plaintiff.
- The specific factual assertion alleged to be false, and evidence supporting falsity.
- The context needed to assess defamatory meaning, opinion, innuendo, and any extrinsic facts.
- Evidence of publication, the defendant’s knowledge or investigation, and the plaintiff’s status.
- Facts bearing on public concern and any applicable privilege.
- Proof of economic, professional, reputational, or emotional harm, and whether the claim is per se or per quod.
Sources & References
- CACI No. 1704. Defamation per se - Essential Factual Elements
- CACI No. 1707. Fact Versus Opinion
- California Civil Code § 46
- Slaughter v. Friedman, 32 Cal. 3d 150 (1982)
- California Civil Code § 45a
- California Civil Code § 45
- Taus v. Loftus, 40 Cal. 4th 683 (2007)
- New York Times Co. v. Sullivan, 376 U.S. 254 (1964)
- California Civil Code § 47