What is the collateral source rule and can a plaintiff sue despite receiving workers compensation benefits?

Yes. In Pennsylvania, an injured worker generally may receive workers’ compensation benefits and also sue a third party whose conduct caused the injury. The employer or its insurer ordinarily has a subrogation claim against the third-party recovery, subject to a share of litigation costs.[5][6]

The collateral source rule

Pennsylvania’s collateral source rule generally prevents a defendant from reducing damages because the injured plaintiff received compensation from an independent source, such as insurance or workers’ compensation. As the Superior Court has explained:

Payments from a collateral source “shall not diminish the damages otherwise recoverable from the wrongdoer.”[2]

The rule generally bars a defendant from introducing evidence that the plaintiff received collateral benefits for the same injuries. Workers’ compensation is ordinarily treated as a collateral source, so an injured worker may generally seek medical expenses and wage losses in a third-party action even if workers’ compensation paid benefits for those losses.[1][2]

The rule’s evidentiary application depends on how the issue arises. In one case, the Superior Court permitted the plaintiff, rather than the defendant, to introduce evidence of the workers’ compensation lien.[2]

Suit against a third party

The Workers’ Compensation Act preserves an injured employee’s ability to sue a responsible third party.[6] Depending on the facts, a third party could be a negligent driver, a property owner, or a manufacturer of defective equipment.

By contrast, workers’ compensation is generally the employee’s exclusive remedy against the employer for a covered workplace injury.[6] Whether a proposed defendant is the employer or a legally distinct third party requires examination of the employment and accident facts.

The workers’ compensation subrogation claim

A third-party recovery does not ordinarily mean the worker retains both the full tort recovery and the compensation benefits. Section 319 provides:

Where the compensable injury is caused “in whole or in part by the act or omission of a third party, the employer shall be subrogated to the right of the employe” against that party “to the extent of the compensation payable.”[5]

The statute also requires the employer to bear a proportionate share of reasonable attorney’s fees and proper litigation disbursements. A recovery exceeding compensation already paid is generally treated as an advance against future compensation installments, making the future-credit calculation important when benefits remain payable.[5]

The tort claim itself generally remains the employee’s. The carrier cannot independently sue the alleged tortfeasor to enforce subrogation when the employee has not assigned the cause of action or voluntarily joined the litigation.[4][3]

The precise damages and lien treatment should be checked against the accident date and applicable statutes, particularly in motor-vehicle cases. Palmosina addressed an older version of Pennsylvania’s motor-vehicle law and should not be assumed to govern every current case.[1]

Sources & References

  1. Palmosina v. Laidlaw Transit Co., Inc., 445 Pa. Super. 121, 664 A.2d 1038 (1995)
  2. Nazarak v. Waite, 2019 PA Super 235
  3. Hartford Ins. Grp. Ex Rel. Chen v. Kamara, No. 24 EAP 2018
  4. Liberty Mutual Insurance Co. v. Domtar Paper Co.
  5. 77 P.S. § 671
  6. 77 P.S. § 481

Related Questions